This incisive project is highly interesting for its eye-catching effect and as a theoretical approach. But the island typology gesture can be put to question. This Sonenstadt suggestion functions very well as an image with its centre of gravity, but in its totality it has the appearance of a playground without a recognisable urban space. The sports area along the railway is to be classified as very useful in programmatic terms.
(excerpt & paraphrase of the jury minutes)